Voicemails for Isabelle Review: Netflix Romcom Picks Creepy Over Cute

The Problematic Premise of Voicemails for Isabelle

Netflix's latest romantic comedy, 'Voicemails for Isabelle,' walks a fine line between humor and unease, but ultimately leans into the latter. The film tells the story of Jill (Zoey Deutch), who leaves voicemails on her late sister's old phone, only to have them received by a stranger, Wes (Nick Robinson). As Wes uses the information to track Jill down and insert himself into her life, the film struggles to balance its tone.

A Blend of Old and New Romantic Comedy Elements

Writer-director Leah McKendrick attempts to blend old and new romantic comedy elements, referencing classic films like 'You've Got Mail' while incorporating modern dating buzzwords like 'gaslit' and 'love bombing.' However, this approach comes across as forced and unconvincing.

The Film's Failure to Deliver Charm

Despite its glossy production and likable leads, 'Voicemails for Isabelle' lacks the required charm to make it an engaging watch. The film's self-referential tone and nods to romantic comedy tropes feel smug and uninteresting.

A Stale and Unengaging Viewing Experience

At almost two hours long, 'Voicemails for Isabelle' tries to have it both ways, downplaying the need for romance while resorting to hackneyed and unearned plot twists. The film's failure to deliver a satisfying conclusion leaves it feeling stale and unengaging.

• Voicemails for Isabelle is now available on Netflix.