Musk Considered Handing OpenAI to His Children, Altman Testifies

The Lead

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman took the stand to defend himself against Elon Musk's lawsuit challenging OpenAI's corporate structure. Musk's lawsuit alleges that OpenAI's founders "stole a charity" when they launched a for-profit subsidiary.

Musk's Allegations and Altman's Response

Altman described Musk's allegations as "difficult to wrap my head around" and emphasized that OpenAI's foundation, with $200 billion in assets, is doing "incredible work." Musk's attorneys pointed out that OpenAI's foundation didn't have full-time employees until earlier this year, but OpenAI board chair Bret Taylor explained that this was due to the challenge of converting equity to cash.

The Safety Commitment Debate

Musk's lawyers questioned whether OpenAI's commitment to safety had been compromised as its commercial power grew. Altman revealed that in 2017, Musk's "specific plans on safety made me worry." He described a pivotal moment when Musk suggested that OpenAI should pass to his children if he were to die.

Altman's Concerns About Musk's Management

Altman testified that Musk's management tactics, which might have worked for engineering and manufacturing, didn't suit OpenAI. He claimed that Musk had demotivated key researchers and damaged the organization's culture. Altman defended the "sweat equity" of fellow cofounders Greg Brockman and Ilya Sutskever.

The Aftermath and Current Lawsuit

Musk ultimately left OpenAI's board and started competing AI initiatives. OpenAI's lawyers noted that Musk had been kept up to date and asked to participate in investments, which his lawsuits now claim corrupted the non-profit. A 2018 discussion about a Microsoft investment was described as a "good vibes meeting" where Musk shared memes on his phone.