Famous Image of JMW Turner Not a Self-Portrait, Expert Claims

The Controversy Surrounding Turner's Portrait

In 2020, Tate Britain hosted the launch of a new £20 banknote bearing representations of The Fighting Temeraire by JMW Turner and the artist's most famous self-portrait. However, a leading expert, Dr. James Hamilton, has now claimed that the latter work, part of the Tate collection, is not by Turner at all.

The Expert's Investigation

Hamilton, who has published books on Turner and staged exhibitions at museums and galleries nationwide, said that while the painting does depict the English Romantic painter, it is likely to be the work of his contemporary, John Opie. Hamilton told the Guardian he started researching the portrait because “there’s nothing else like it in Turner’s work”.

The Attribution Debate

Hamilton believes the portrait was misattributed after being included among nearly 300 oil paintings and 30,000 sketches and watercolours in the Turner Bequest following the artist’s death in 1851. He concluded that stylistic evidence points to Opie, who depicted his sitters in a similar “light emerging dramatically from dark”.

The Impact on Turner's Legacy

The painting, dated c1799 when Turner was 24, was created by a master portrait painter with “brilliant dexterity”, Hamilton added. If Hamilton's claims are correct, it could have significant implications for Turner's legacy and the art world's understanding of his work.

The Future of the Portrait's Attribution

A Tate spokesperson said: “As the home of the Turner Bequest, we always welcome new ideas about Turner’s life and new interpretations of his work. We look forward to exploring James Hamilton’s research further.”