Hearts' Title Dreams Shattered as Celtic Retain Scottish Premiership in Dramatic Fashion

The Final Day Heartbreak

Another final-day showdown, another final-day heartbreak for Hearts. The pain may have been spread over 61 years, but that won't make it any easier to bear for Hearts who, having been top for 250 days of the Scottish Premiership season, missed out on the title once again.

There was, of course, a Celtic penalty for handball and a critical video assistant referee decision that went their way, but on this occasion, neither provided the controversy. That came instead from the confusion as the game was ended by a pitch invasion with 23 seconds plus whatever else the referee felt needed to be added to injury still to play.

The Dramatic Finale

For Martin O'Neill, the Celtic manager, this was a remarkable finale. At 74, he has his fourth Scottish title, and surely the most remarkable, achieved by winning the final eight games of the league season. That may become a double if Celtic can beat Dunfermline in the Scottish Cup final next week.

Hearts had led the league for much of the season, but their hopes were crushed when Daizen Maeda squeezed in a goal with just four minutes remaining, putting Celtic in front. The late goal sealed Celtic's title retention and sent Hearts players and supporters into despair.

The Historical Context

This wasn't the first time Hearts have experienced final-day agony. In 1965, Kilmarnock beat them 2-0 at Tynecastle to take the title by 0.04 goal-difference. And in 1986, they went to Dundee on the final day needing a draw and lost 2-0 to a pair of Albert Kidd goals in the final seven minutes as Celtic took the title on goal difference.

Whatever the outcome, this was a day that was going to live forever in the history of the club. Everybody will have their tale, whether they were among the 752 making up the official allocation at Celtic Park, or among the many thousands packing the bars of Edinburgh's Gorgie, or simply watching at home.

The Fan Experience

There have been breakout stories, those of fans who remember Hearts' last league title, in 1960, experienced the two previous final-day agonies, and assumed they would never see their side even have a chance of winning the league again. The most notable, perhaps, has been the 73-year-old singer Colin Chisholm, who has become a feature over the past few weeks, leading communal singalongs of the Hearts Song.

These are the days that give purpose to the drab 1-0 home defeats, to the freezing afternoons watching terrible football, to the erratic owners and grim relegations: there's enormous emotional debt to be paid for even the possibility of a high such as Saturday might have provided.

The Future of Scottish Football

That does raise the question of whether this is a one-off. Tony Bloom with his Jamestown Analytics data model has brought success to Brighton in England and to Union Saint-Gilloise in Belgium. Why should it not work again next season for Hearts?

But then Celtic are unlikely to appoint Wilfried Nancy for a second time, or Rangers Russell Martin. That's the flip side of this season: well as Hearts have played, it's exposed just how poorly the Glaswegian giants are run, how their parochial wrangling has blinded them to developments elsewhere and left them exposed to just such a challenge.

Hearts may not go away, but Celtic will not be this bad again. Hearts will hope, and Scottish football should hope, that this level of competitiveness can be sustained. Other clubs, perhaps, can draw encouragement that the big two are not quite invincible. Hearts have shown a way, and all of Scottish football should thank them for that.