French Film on Nazi Collaboration Sparks Controversy

Xavier Giannoli's latest film, 'Rays and Shadows,' has ignited a firestorm of controversy in France with its portrayal of Jean Luchaire, a French journalist and press baron who collaborated with the Nazis during World War II. The film, told from the perspective of Luchaire's daughter Corinne, a former actress known as 'the new Garbo,' delves into the moral compromises and betrayals of occupied France.

The film's depiction of Luchaire as a disillusioned spendthrift rather than a diehard ideologue has sparked criticism from left-leaning critics, who argue that it relativizes the actions of those who willingly served the Nazi killing machine. Historian Laurent Joly also questions the film's portrayal of Luchaire, suggesting that his path to collaboration was driven by amorality and venality rather than pacifism.

Despite the controversy, the film has drawn over 300,000 spectators in its opening week in France, sparking important discussions about the Vichy period and the complexities of human behavior during times of war. Giannoli's goal was to strike a balance between fascination and indignation, and to explore the traps that a human being can fall into when faced with difficult choices.