Beef Season 2 Falls Short of Its Dark and Thought-Provoking Predecessor

The second season of Beef has arrived on Netflix, but it seems to have lost the magic that made the first season so compelling. Critic Lucy Mangan argues that the show has become an unlovable White Lotus rip-off, with a similar premise but lacking the depth and nuance that made The White Lotus so impactful.

The new season stars Carey Mulligan and Oscar Isaac as a married couple who oversee the running of a luxury country club. Their characters, Josh and Lindsay, are frustrated with where life has led them – close to wealth but far from achieving it. They are joined by their employees, Austin and Ashley, who become entangled in their problems.

As the season progresses, the plot becomes increasingly convoluted with too many characters and complications introduced. The tension, which was so expertly ratcheted up in the first season, becomes diluted. Much is gestured towards but nothing is satisfactorily interrogated, including themes of racial tension, ageing, and the precarity of jobs.

The characters themselves are also criticized for being hard to care about. Lindsay is described as a 'cold, hard spoilt brat', while Josh is weak and unconvincing. Austin is a cipher, and even Ashley, who is better served, has actions that feel forced.

Overall, Beef season two feels like an entertaining but shallow potboiler rather than the dark march towards truth that the original was. It seems that the show has failed to live up to the standard set by its predecessor and The White Lotus.