Entertainment
Jun 05, 2026
Half Man Review: Is Richard Gadd's Bleakest TV Series Too Unpleasant to Be Good?
The Guardian reviews Richard Gadd's 'Half Man,' a follow-up to his hit 'Baby Reindeer,' finding it …
The Verdict on Richard Gadd's Bleakest Work YetRichard Gadd returns to television with 'Half Man,' a project that stands in stark contrast to the psychological thriller of his previous hit, 'Baby Reindeer.' While the show is technically proficient, the Guardian's review suggests it is so relentlessly bleak and violent that it borders on 'torture pornography.' The article argues that despite the intense performances and clever framing, the show lacks the emotional light required to be considered a success in traditional television terms.A Descent into 'Torture Pornography' and Unrelenting ViolenceThe core of the critique centers on the show's brutality. The protagonist, Ruben, is depicted as a mindless thug whose temper reaches violent peaks, with beatings described as 'numerous and graphic.' The review notes that the show is so dark that even its subplot about a suicidal cancer patient is considered one of its 'least depressing aspects.' The characters are trapped in a cycle of misery and self-medication, creating a viewing experience that is difficult to stomach.Half Man as a Referendum on the Baby Reindeer ControversyA significant portion of the analysis focuses on the show's meta-commentary on the 'Baby Reindeer' controversy. The plot involves a character writing a book about his experiences, leading to a press conference where he is frustrated by journalists demanding to know if it is based on a real person. This serves as a 'right of reply' for Gadd, who was stalked and abused in real life. However, the review suggests this self-interrogation is overshadowed by the sheer unpleasantness of the content.The Future of Dark TV: Is Unpleasantness a Substitute for Substance?The article draws comparisons to other dark series like 'Black Mirror' and 'The Leftovers,' noting that while those shows eventually pivoted to irony or absurdism to alleviate the gloom, 'Half Man' remains trapped in its misery. The review concludes that the show feels like it was made by a '14-year-old emo acting out to get noticed,' contrasting it with 'Adolescence' which is described as a show about men made by men. This raises questions about the sustainability of pure, unyielding despair in modern television.
#Richard Gadd
#Half Man
#BBC
Read More