Lifestyle
May 26, 2026
Emily Wilson's Translation Philosophy: Bridging Ancient and Modern Worlds
Emily Wilson's new book 'Crossing the Wine Dark Sea' explores the art of translation through classi…
The Lead
Emily Wilson, renowned for her acclaimed translations of Homer's Odyssey and Iliad, presents a new collection of essays exploring the art and challenges of translation. Her work has become the standard English-language versions of these classics, praised for their conciseness and fluency.
The Translation Philosophy
Wilson's approach to translation occupies a middle ground between the "familiarisers" who prioritize accessibility and the "foreignisers" who emphasize preserving the strangeness of the original. She believes the tensions and complexities of the original should always remain legible, while also creating a reader-friendly experience. This balance is evident in her choice to use iambic pentameter for the Odyssey, honoring Homer's dactylic hexameters without being slavishly literal.
Classical Insights
The book delves into how the ancient world intersects with the modern, examining continuities in war, cruelty, and political turmoil while also highlighting important contrasts. Wilson critiques those who view antiquity as merely "a mirror in which we always find ourselves," arguing for a more nuanced understanding. Her analysis extends from classical authors like Aeschylus and Aristophanes to modern figures like Spike Lee and Boris Johnson, demonstrating the timeless relevance of these texts.
Translating Sappho
Wilson addresses the unique challenges of translating Sappho, whose work survives only in fragments. She compares it to "trying to get a sense of a whole Tyrannosaurus rex from one claw." While mostly admiring Anne Carson's version as "performance art on the page," Wilson finds it disembodied and stripped of same-sex desire. She challenges feminist readings that position male poets as metaphorically raping Sappho while female poets sing with her, instead emphasizing how Sappho's work "emphasise the isolation of the individual."
Critiquing Other Translators
Wilson doesn't shy away from criticism, applying tough-minded standards to fellow translators. She dismisses Robert Browning's version of Agamemnon as "arguably more difficult to understand than the Greek" and accuses Edith Hamilton of racism for "remaking ancient Greece in the image of an idealized United States." Even respected translators like Peter Green are found to be "oddly stiff" at times. She reserves particular scorn for "armchair classicists" who engage in snobbish gatekeeping, positioning herself as an accessible champion of the classics.
The Sirens' Seduction
One fascinating section explores Wilson's approach to translating the Sirens' scene in the Odyssey. She challenges the modern perception of Sirens as sexual temptresses, noting that Homer's Sirens are "cognitively tempting" bird-women whose seduction promises knowledge, not sex. Rather than referring to their "lips" as many translators do, Wilson uses "mouths," emphasizing their dangerous nature over any sexual appeal.
Choosing "Complicated"
Wilson details her decision to translate Homer's description of Odysseus as "polytropos" as "complicated," acknowledging it might sound stark but defending it as capturing the character's complexity. She admits nearly dropping the term after encountering "He's a complicated man" in Isaac Hayes's Shaft theme song but ultimately embraced it, dedicating ten pages to explaining her choice.
The Future of Translation
In a manifesto-like afterword, Wilson offers 20 rules for translators, emphasizing the importance of recreating the emotional impact of the original text. "If the original makes you laugh, cry, feel excited, get goosebumps, feel puzzled, get bored, be charmed," she advises, "then the translation should try to create those effects." She encourages experimentation and persistence, noting that there's always another way to say things and that future generations will undoubtedly develop new approaches to translation.
#Emily Wilson
#Homer
#Translation
Read More