Politics
May 27, 2026
UK Ministers Urged to Proceed with Zero-Hours Contracts Ban Despite Business Warnings
Campaigners are urging UK ministers to proceed with banning zero-hours contracts despite business w…
The Lead: Zero-Hours Contracts Divide Ministers and BusinessesMinisters should press ahead with a ban on zero-hours contracts, campaigners say, despite claims by business leaders that it would deter hiring and lock more young people out of the labour market. The Child Poverty Action Group and the union umbrella organisation the TUC were among eight signatories to a letter to the department of business and trade calling on the government to "ignore the noise" from businesses, which want zero-hours contracts to remain.The Political Standoff: Campaigners vs. Business LeadersThe debate over zero-hours contracts has created a clear divide between worker advocates and business interests. Campaigners argue that these contracts create insecurity for workers, while business leaders warn that banning them would reduce flexibility and potentially lead to fewer jobs. The British Retail Consortium and UKHospitality have written to Business Secretary Peter Kyle stating that reduced flexibility in work contracts will lead to fewer jobs. Meanwhile, a new report by the Institute of Directors showed that 86% of business leaders believe the Employment Rights Act will have a negative impact on UK economic growth, up from 72% a year ago.The Regulatory Timeline: From Royal Assent to Implementation DelayLast year, the Employment Rights Act gained royal assent, but many of the detailed provisions were left blank, allowing ministers to phase in implementation over a period of years. Peter Kyle, the business secretary, has overseen a delay in the launch of a planned consultation on zero-hours contracts that was due to begin in January. It is understood the department will ask for submissions before the end of the summer, before implementing new rules next year. Business leaders are concerned that delays in the consultation process will not give them time to adjust their workplace practices if new rules are agreed.The Economic Impact: Business Leaders' ConcernsBusiness leaders have expressed significant concerns about the potential economic consequences of banning zero-hours contracts. Lord Wolfson, chair of the retailer Next, stated that while he favours eliminating zero-hours contracts in most sectors, the new rules would prove costly for retailers "because the risk is you then have to contract for those hours for ever." The Institute of Directors report highlighting that 86% of business leaders believe the Employment Rights Act will negatively impact UK economic growth underscores the depth of business concern about this regulatory change.The Worker Perspective: Insecurity and PovertyFrom the workers' perspective, zero-hours contracts create significant financial insecurity. More than a million people in the UK work to a zero-hours contract, from hospitality and warehouses to the NHS. Hundreds of thousands of them have worked for the same employer for years, yet lack guaranteed hours. Paul Nowak, the TUC general secretary, noted that many workers do not know how much they will earn each week, "and lack of security over hours makes it hard for workers to plan their lives, budget and look after their children." Many are unable to get mortgages and other forms of cheap credit when employers can reduce their hours to zero. Alison Garnham, chief executive of the Child Poverty Action Group, emphasized how these contracts affect working parents: "All too often working parents find themselves without enough to make ends meet – as their hours are cut at a moment's notice or they pay for childcare only to find their shifts are cancelled."The Government's Dilemma: Balancing Rights and Business InterestsThe government faces a difficult balancing act between protecting workers' rights and maintaining a business-friendly environment. The upcoming report by former health secretary Alan Milburn is expected to accuse the government of failing to meet the needs of young people out of work, education and training, putting further pressure on Business Secretary Peter Kyle to show that new employment laws will support job creation. The TUC has attempted to address business concerns by noting that the right to a regular-hours contract would not affect holiday jobs as it "is set to be based on a reference period over several months which will even out peaks and troughs." Other signatories to the letter urging action include the women's rights group the Fawcett Society, the employment thinktank the Work Foundation, and the campaigning organisations 38 Degrees and the Young Women's Trust.
#Zero-Hours Contracts
#UK Employment Law
#TUC
Read More