Politics
May 25, 2026
Miliband Advocates 'Separate Bedrooms' for Europe and US, Rejects Complete Divorce
Former UK Foreign Secretary David Miliband argues Europe should seek greater strategic autonomy fro…
The LeadFormer Labour Foreign Secretary David Miliband has delivered a nuanced perspective on Europe's relationship with the United States, advocating for increased European autonomy while stopping short of suggesting a complete break from the transatlantic alliance. Speaking at the Hay literary festival, Miliband used the metaphor of 'separate bedrooms, maybe. Divorce, no,' to describe his vision for the future of Europe-US relations amid growing tensions under the Trump administration.The Strategic Autonomy DebateMiliband explicitly rejected the argument that strategic autonomy for Europe necessitates divorce from the United States, warning of the dangers of such a path. Instead, he suggested Europe needs to develop greater 'agency' in economic and military matters. This includes addressing challenges in defense procurement, where European nations often purchase either European or American equipment, and in the realm of artificial intelligence, where achieving digital sovereignty remains particularly challenging.When pressed on practical implications, Miliband humorously added that Europe would also need 'separate bank accounts,' indicating a desire for greater financial independence while maintaining the broader alliance framework.The Economic Disparity AnalysisA key factor in Miliband's analysis is the significant economic disparity between Europe and the United States. He highlighted that US GDP per capita is nearly twice that of Europe's in nominal terms, which he identified as a core weakness affecting Europe's political and military capabilities. Miliband emphasized that generating wealth and distributing it fairly is essential for addressing these weaknesses and strengthening Europe's global position.The climate issue emerged as a critical area where Miliband believes Europe must lead regardless of US policy direction. 'There's a massive economic interest as well as an environmental interest in Europe being at the absolute forefront,' he stated, suggesting that Europe cannot afford to be held back by American policy reversals on climate issues.The Transatlantic Impact AnalysisThe panel discussion, which also featured writer and lawyer Philippe Sands and philosopher Susan Neiman, revealed growing concerns about the current state of transatlantic relations. Sands characterized the UK-US relationship as 'one-way,' noting that Britain is 'far more dependent' on the US than vice versa. He argued that Britain's 'primary connection' is with Europe, suggesting a need to realign post-Brexit.Sands emphasized that Britain 'will not be seen as a reliable partner' by France and other European nations, indicating significant diplomatic work ahead. The discussion also addressed Brexit's economic impact, with moderator Misha Glenny noting that it has demonstrated to other EU member states the catastrophic consequences of disengaging from regulatory alignment.The Future OutlookMiliband's comments build upon his recent call for a 'national consensus' over the UK's position on rejoining the EU, following reports of a rejected proposal to create a single market for goods with the European Union. He addressed concerns that rapprochement with Europe would betray leave voters, stating that 'immiserating ourselves or making us less secure honours the Brexit vote. The opposite is actually the case.'The former foreign secretary also commented on global conflicts, suggesting that the 'break in the international system' represented by the war in Iran was 'bigger' than the one represented by the war in Iraq, noting that this conflict has broken relationships between America and Europe in a way he hadn't previously witnessed.
#David Miliband
#Europe-US Relations
#Brexit
Read More