Breaking AI & Tech News Analyzed

The Future of Warfare: AI-Powered Drones Should the AI-powered drones of the future have a licence to kill? The question is becoming ever more pressing as governments and the defence industry acknowledge that drone systems will play an increasingly crucial role in future warfare. The Moral Dilemma of Autonomous Weapons With drones being deployed in huge numbers in the Ukraine war and AI being used to assist bombing missions in the Iran conflict, there is an expectation among some observers that weapons will have to operate with increased operational autonomy, which means they will need something approximating a moral framework. Expert Opinions on AI and Morality Last year Mustafa Suleyman, chief executive of Microsoft’s AI arm and a co-founder of the UK-based DeepMind, was unequivocal about the issue of machines making moral decisions. He said: “AIs cannot be people – or moral beings.” David Omand, the former head of the UK spy agency, GCHQ, believes AI can create a “moral” configuration for unmanned weapons. The UK armed forces minister, Al Carns, told the Financial Times recently there must be an option to “take the human out of the loop” in decision-making. The Challenges of Programming Morality Zee Talat, an academic specialising in machine learning at the University of Edinburgh’s school of informatics, argues that large language models – the technology that underpins modern generative AI systems such as chatbots – are fundamentally incapable of moral decision-making. “If you have a machine that’s probabilistic by nature it will veer towards the most likely answer in a situation. Do we think that morality follows probabilistic notions?” The Debate on Autonomous Weapons Governance Jessica Dorsey, an assistant professor of international law at Utrecht University in the Netherlands, raises concerns about determining whose morality the drone is following, given the United Nations is still trying to achieve a global consensus on autonomous weapons governance. “War is filled with so many variables and it is a given that things will go wrong. And when that happens at AI-like speed, it is difficult to unravel.” The Future of AI-Powered Drones Some experts argue that giving drones greater autonomy, and programming rules of engagement and morality into them, will be a necessity if other nation states continue to develop and deploy similar technology at pace. Nicholas Wright, a neuroscientist and author of Warhead, a book on the human brain and war, says: “For any military to compete effectively against other high-end militaries it is going to need a large amount of systems that will be required to take decisions on their own.” Olaf Hichwa, the co-founder of Neros, a US drone startup, believes that drones will not replace human decision-makers, but enhance the abilities of their human pilots.

The Electric Journey of Wimmy Road Boyz Sufiyaan Salam's debut novel, "Wimmy Road Boyz," presents a high-octane narrative following three British Pakistani twentysomethings as they navigate one transformative night on Manchester's Curry Mile. Written in distinctive Gen Z lowercase and multilingual prose, the novel blends cultural references, social commentary, and raw emotion to create a unique literary experience that challenges traditional narratives of British Asian identity. A Night of Transformation on Manchester's Curry Mile The novel centers on three friends—Immy, Khan, and Haris—each seeking escape from their personal struggles. As they cruise through "Wimmy Road," described as a "shisha-haze mecca of mischief and magic," the journey becomes a metaphor for the British Asian experience. The setting transforms from a vibrant cultural hub to a "colossal no man's land," reflecting the deteriorating mood of the characters and the fractures within their friendship. This narrative device effectively mirrors the complex relationship between British Asian youth and their cultural heritage. Literary Reception and Publication Impact Published by Merky Books at £16.99, "Wimmy Road Boyz" has been recognized for its innovative style and authentic portrayal of British Asian masculinity. The novel has drawn comparisons to literary giants like Salman Rushdie and Hanif Kureishi, establishing Salam as a significant new voice in contemporary British literature. The book's release represents an important moment for diverse voices in publishing, particularly for narratives that challenge the "good immigrant" stereotype and explore the complexities of cultural identity. Challenging Cultural Narratives in Modern Britain Beyond its entertainment value, "Wimmy Road Boyz" serves as a profound commentary on the British Asian male experience. The novel confronts societal expectations, historical traumas (including references to the 1947 partition), and the limitations imposed by cultural stereotypes. Through the characters' internal monologues and interactions, Salam examines the "deep-set silences, fractures and loneliness" that many British Asian men experience, challenging readers to consider how historical and contemporary forces shape individual identity. The Future of British Asian Literature With its innovative style and unflinching examination of cultural identity, "Wimmy Road Boyz" signals a new direction for British Asian literature. The novel's success suggests a growing appetite for authentic, diverse narratives that challenge traditional publishing norms. As Salam demonstrates, there is significant power in reclaiming cultural narratives and giving voice to experiences that have historically been marginalized. This debut may pave the way for more authors to explore similar themes, potentially leading to a richer, more inclusive literary landscape that better reflects contemporary Britain.

The Lead Tehran, Iran – In the popular Bastan market in the west of the Iranian capital, where the inviting smell of fresh bread and fruit mingle with the sight of colourful fabrics and clothing, the scene no longer holds its usual joy. Passersby wander among the vendors' stalls, carefully turning goods over only to return them to their places. Everyday Survival in a Hyperinflation Economy "Daily shopping trips have turned into something resembling a reconnaissance mission to find out the new prices," says Mashhadi Firouz, a 63-year-old retiree. "A year ago, a kilo of rice was about 1.8 million rials ($1.31), but today it has crossed the 5-million-rial ($3.63) threshold." Similarly, a bottle of cooking oil has increased from 700,000 rials ($0.51) to more than 3 million rials ($2.18). Fatima, 46, a housewife and mother of three, explains: "I now go to the market three times a week instead of once, not because I need anything, but to see if there is a seller who has goods at a lower price." She adds, "Red meat has become a dream, chicken has become a mere guest on our table, and I have even started counting eggs one by one." The Economic Statistics Behind the Crisis A new report by the Central Bank of Iran revealed a historic jump in the annual inflation rate, reaching 77.2 percent year-on-year in the period between April 21 and May 20, with a monthly increase of 8.5 percent. Furthermore, point-to-point inflation for goods reached 113 percent. This is Iran's highest inflation rate since 1942, during World War II. The Perfect Economic Storm Arman Khaleghi, head of Iran's Chamber of Commerce, Industries and Mines, points to what he describes as a "perfect economic storm" of five factors that have all poured down simultaneously on the Iranian economy. These include: the elimination of the preferential currency, protests at the beginning of the year, the [US-Israeli] "Ramadan War," annual increases in wages and energy prices, and finally the naval blockade that hindered import and export chains. War's Impact on Consumer Behavior "With the outbreak of the war, people rushed to hoard basic goods, such as food and detergents," explains Khaleghi. "Demand jumped despite there being no real shortage in the markets, and this feverish rush alone is enough to drive up prices." The damage inflicted on primary industries, led by petrochemicals, has driven up packaging costs for the food, pharmaceutical and detergent industries, transmitting the contagion of inflation from the factory to the store shelf. The Maritime Blockade's Effect The maritime blockade has made travelling to Iran a perilous mission for cargo ships. "Even the mere news of a ship being targeted immediately raises prices, let alone the existence of actual difficulties and palpable shortages that have forced the search for more expensive alternative land routes," states Khaleghi. The Wage Paradox "The decision to raise wages and salaries was intended to compensate for the effects of the removal of the preferential currency rate and to preserve the purchasing power of the working class," explains Khaleghi. "However, the increase, which seemed substantial on paper, proved entirely insufficient in reality. The result is a sharp decline in real purchasing power, which begins by devouring household savings, then preys on health, medical, and education budgets, until it ultimately impacts daily sustenance." The Vicious Cycle of Economic Decline Khaleghi warns of a vicious cycle closing in on the economy: "We are in a situation where the state itself is bearing the brunt of the economic slowdown. Tax revenues, which were supposed to offset part of the cost of the preferential currency reforms, are also shrinking. Thus, we are faced with an impossible equation: the citizen's income is melting away, the state's income is eroding, and prices continue to soar to heights unseen in decades." Standing on the Edge of an Economic Iceberg "You would think the market is alive, but it is clinically dead," says Reza, 47, a shop owner. "People come here because the market is the last free place for entertainment. They wander aimlessly, remembering the days when they used to enter shopping malls and leave with bags that filled their car trunks." Mahmoud, 37, a lecturer at a private university, offers a historical perspective: "The country used to cover its wounds with petrodollars, and now that the effect of the anaesthetic has worn off, all the ailments have surfaced at once." He adds, "What worries me is not just the price hikes, but the experts' estimates of the consequences of flawed economic policies that have not yet emerged, because they have effectively hidden behind the noise of the war. This means we are standing on the edge of an iceberg; what we see now is only the tip."

Discovering New Voices in Poetry A recent review roundup from The Guardian showcases a diverse selection of poetry collections, each offering unique perspectives and styles. The review highlights six exceptional works, providing insight into the world of contemporary poetry. Haunting the Black Air by Anthony Joseph Joseph's follow-up to his TS Eliot prize-winning Sonnets for Albert sees his poetic approach become more radical. He pays homage to avant-garde writers such as Will Alexander and Nathaniel Mackey, while exploring themes of nostalgia, grief, and magnetic feelings. Selected Poems by Leontia Flynn Flynn's collection is a glorious reintroduction to her mordant wit, imaginative image-making, and unerring ability to puncture pretension. Her poems remain fresh and relevant, even after more than 20 years of publishing. You Must Live: New Poetry from Palestine This anthology features over 30 poets living in Gaza and the West Bank, with work written in the last few years. The poems testify to the resilience of the artists and the role that poetry still has to give voice and bear witness in times of crisis. Melete by Jennifer Lee Tsai Lee Tsai's debut is a sprawling mix of poetry and prose exploring second-generation Chinese identity in the UK. The book feels roughly hewn, fiercely articulating the need to write and create something beautiful. Sparrow on the Rooftop by Rachel Long Long's second collection has replaced the playfulness of her debut with a directness of diction and image. The poems pull you up with their unflinching gaze, tackling topics such as alcoholism, eating disorders, and grief. Somebody Should Have Pressed Record by Galia Admoni Admoni's narrative poem explores the premise of starting a relationship with an imaginary version of an actor. Her tone is reminiscent of Georges Perec, both in its jabs at contemporary living and in what it reveals about the difficulties we have in making sense of ourselves in the absence of others.

The Enduring Magic of Baseball Baseball's relationship with superstitions and curses stretches back to its earliest days, with the infamous Curse of the Billy Goat being just one example. When Chicago bar owner William Sianis was denied entry to the 1945 World Series with his pet goat Murphy, he allegedly cursed the team, which then went 71 years without winning another championship. This story, along with countless other rituals and beliefs, forms the foundation of baseball's unique relationship with the magical and supernatural. A New Book Explores Baseball's Mystical Side Author, journalist, and New York Mets fan Addy Baird has chronicled baseball's rich tradition of superstitions in her new book, "The Magical Game: The Spirit and History of Baseball's Superstitions, Rituals, and Curses." Baird became fascinated with baseball's magical elements while cheering for the Mets, finding herself becoming increasingly superstitious as the team had successful stretches. "I changed the way I acted, things I did, wore, watched, said, ate," she admits, trying to influence the team's performance through her own rituals. Legendary Superstitions and Rituals The book documents numerous baseball superstitions throughout history. Turn-of-the-century managers like Connie Mack and John McGraw relied on human mascots to bring their teams good luck. Wade Boggs famously ate chicken before every game during his career in the 1980s and 1990s. More recently, a Seattle Mariners fan believes that holding a pair of slippers somehow negatively affected his team's performance, while a Tampa Bay Rays fan plays Middle Earth music during difficult innings despite having no interest in Lord of the Rings. Even in softball, superstitions persist—this week it was revealed that a top college player eats ladybugs in the dugout for good luck. The Psychology Behind Baseball's Magic When asked what makes baseball particularly prone to magical thinking, Baird identifies several factors: the presence of luck, the game's unique structure, and its repetitive nature. "Basically, when a sport has fewer instances of scoring, luck is a bigger factor," she explains. Baseball's structure is also distinctive as "one of the only games we play, and the only major North American sport, where the defense has the ball," creating an uncertain environment. The repetitive nature of the game—with batters facing dozens of pitches over a 162-game season—further compounds the uncertainty, creating what Baird calls "a perfect environment for magic to thrive." Baseball's Mythological Foundations Baird connects baseball's structure to ancient mythological patterns, noting that MLB's official historian John Thorn observed that "the form of the game itself mirrors that of the Odyssey." The nine innings represent the hero's journey: starting at home, facing potential failure, and embarking on a journey with the goal of returning home. "The story of this myth is embedded in the game itself. Magic is in its very structure," Baird concludes. This connection helps explain why baseball has developed such rich traditions and superstitions throughout its history. Evolution of Baseball's Magic The book also examines how recent changes to baseball, including sabermetrics and new rules like the pitch clock, might affect the game's magical elements. Initially, Baird believed these changes were killing baseball's magic, but her research revealed a long tradition of people claiming "baseball is dying" since the 1860s. She now believes "the game should evolve, an unchanging thing is a dead thing." Interestingly, she finds that sabermetrics actually "help us to see what makes [baseball] unique, what makes it special, what makes players exceptionally good... Those numbers reveal to us the magic." Baseball's Appeal Beyond the Field Through her research, Baird not only completed a manuscript but also discovered a new career path. In addition to her journalism work, she has become a practicing astrologer. "It was one of my really interesting side quests," she says. "I do readings for people, reading charts." Whether you're a baseball enthusiast or someone interested in magic and ritual, "The Magical Game" offers something for everyone. As Baird explains, "it's a book for people who love baseball, also for those who do not care about baseball at all" and "for the people who love magic, looking at it through a lens they may never have considered before."

The LeadThis week's top picks for TV include a mix of classic films and recent releases. From Pixar's latest to classic Hammer horrors, there's something for everyone. Pick of the Week: Hoppers“We’re all in this together.” It may seem an obvious eco message to be pushing at the kids who will flock to watch the latest Pixar animation. But when it’s done as charmingly as in Daniel Chong’s sci-fi comedy adventure, you’d be hard-pressed not to cheer along with the film’s endangered animals. Mabel (voiced by Piper Curda) is our teenage human guide to a biodiverse nook of woods and water near Beaverton. But when a proposed freeway causes the wildlife to scatter, she “hops” her mind into a robotic beaver (invented by her biology teacher) so she can track them down and save their glade. Crammed with neat gags, relatable villains and a shark assassin named Diane, it’s cute propaganda. Out now, Disney+ The Curse of FrankensteinThe first in what would be a distinguished line of colourful “Hammer horrors”, Terence Fisher’s 1957 adaptation of Mary Shelley’s novel still packs a punch. Unable to copy the pathos-tinged Boris Karloff look, the film-makers fashioned a creature with a grey, clammy pallor and irredeembly violent tendencies. He doesn’t even turn up until halfway, but luckily Peter Cushing – in his first movie starring role – commands the screen as the hubristic Baron Frankenstein, a monomaniac diving gleefully off the ethical deep end. Saturday 6 June, 9.05pm, Talking Pictures TV VermiglioThe simple, traditional life of an Italian mountain community butts up against the frictions exposed by the second world war in Maura Delpero’s sensitive, beautiful drama. Tommaso Ragno wields his forbidding white moustache well as local teacher, and father of eight, Cesare. He is harbouring two army deserters: his nephew and the lad’s Sicilian friend Pietro. But then his eldest daughter Lucia falls for Pietro, disturbing the family’s balance of power and stress-testing parental and gender norms to the brink of collapse. Saturday 6 June, 9.20pm, BBC Four The Beautiful GameFor better or worse, out come the footie films for the World Cup. Thea Sharrock’s quirky comedy is one of the niftier ones. Based on a true story, it revolves round the Homeless World Cup. Bill Nighy is his usual wryly comic self as Mal, the manager of the England squad – young men all with tragic backstories – as they head to the tournament in Rome. Mal’s secret weapon is Vinny (Micheal Ward), who nearly made it as a pro but is now a bundle of resentment. The social issues are only touched on, but the “no I in team” moral is loud and clear. Sunday 7 June, 3.35pm, Channel 4 NomadlandChloé Zhao’s moving 2020 drama is one of those rare Oscar winners that feels like an instant classic. It is a portrait of America’s “nomads” – mostly middle-aged loners whose home is their RVs, as they seek out seasonal work and form temporary communities. Acting among an array of real-life travellers, Frances McDormand is a case study in less is more as widow Fern, who heads out into the wide vistas of her nation to discover if this is a meaningful life or merely existing. Sunday 7 June, 1am, Channel 4 The ChoralTODO

The Dark Side of Creativity Children’s writers are sometimes cruel, and often damaged. And, as AS Byatt put it crisply when talking about her 2009 novel The Children’s Book: “Writing children’s books isn’t good for the writer’s own children.” Think of Christopher Milne, raging at having been Christopher Robin; Vivian Burnett, dragging Little Lord Fauntleroy behind him; Alastair Grahame, lying down on train tracks. The Trapped Protagonist This is fertile material, as Byatt recognised, for a grown-up book. The American author Melissa Albert, herself a very successful children’s writer, has made it the theme of her first adult novel. The Children’s protagonist is Guinevere Sharpe, who as a grown woman is trapped by a very public version of her childhood. Her mother, Edith, a sort of JK Rowling/Enid Blyton composite, wrote an era-defining run of children’s portal fantasies called the Ninth City series, in which Guin and her older brother Ennis appeared as the named protagonists. The Unraveling of a Family Their marriage turns toxic. Edith is remote and frosty. The loving and boisterous Llewellyn is stricken by an unspecified illness and the light starts to go out of him. And the children, devoted to each other and freed from the necessity of formal schooling, are left to their own devices. Meanwhile, there’s something very spooky about their old wooden house. Occult artefacts surface. Its inhabitants have disturbing dreams. Edith shows up one day with a missing finger. Unraveling the Mystery In the present tense of the novel, meanwhile, Edith and Llewellyn have died in a fire that consumed the house; the sixth and last book in the Ninth City series never got written; and Guin and Ennis, once so close, have been on nonspeakers for two decades. A conceptual artist who builds uncanny installations, Ennis has always refused to talk about his childhood and the Ninth City books – but just as Guin is publicising her memoir, he announces a new show called Mother. The Cost of Creativity What we know about the Ninth City series – that in its universe there’s a vampiric figure called the Architect who steals the dreams of children to build constantly shifting fantasy worlds – casts an ominous shadow over Guin’s story. You get a hunch Albert is saying something here about the creative process, and the cost of it. Edith is a brilliant children’s writer – but she’s not quite right. A Complex but Flawed Novel That bumper crop of mysteries is also a slight weakness of this very readable and intriguing book. There’s simply so much going on that the force of the story dissipates: Edith never comes fully into focus; Guin’s crumbling relationship with her fiance, Hank, though acutely described, struggles to carry the weight it wants to; the ending is a little rushed.

Breathing Earth's Ancient PastMore than 2bn years ago, during the Paleoproterozoic era, the Earth's atmosphere began to fill with free oxygen, enabling the rise of aerobic life and, ultimately, humans. This Great Oxidation Event is now being experienced firsthand by visitors to the Museum of Old and New Art (Mona) in Tasmania, where French-Swiss conceptual artist Julian Charrière has created an extraordinary installation that allows people to inhale oxygen that has been trapped in iron ore since that ancient time.When Charrière came up with the concept for what would become 'Breathe,' Mona's owner David Walsh not only approved the project but created a bespoke space for it, recognizing the unique intersection of science, art, and human experience that the installation represents.The Science Behind the Ancient OxygenThe installation is a marvel of scientific ingenuity and artistic vision. Charrière has sourced ancient iron ore from Australia's Pilbara region, which is processed daily in an on-site laboratory. The water is extracted from the ore using specialized machinery, then put through a Hofmann apparatus—a piece of scientific equipment that electrolyzes water—to liberate the trapped oxygen molecules.This pure, ancient oxygen is then released into a specially designed room where visitors can breathe it in, creating a direct connection to the beginning of life on Earth. As Charrière explains: 'I want people to get all the way back to the beginning of the earth. It's like a time machine.' The installation is designed as a solitary experience, with visitors accessing a vault-like corridor reminiscent of a mining drift, flanked by raw sandstone and lined with deep red rocks from the Pilbara.The Immense Timescale of the InstallationThe timescale involved in 'Breathe' is almost incomprehensible. The oxygen visitors inhale has been trapped in iron ore for over 2.4 billion years—since the Great Oxidation Event that transformed Earth's atmosphere and enabled the development of complex life forms. This installation literally connects each visitor to the primordial beginnings of our planet's atmosphere.As visitors walk through the tunnel, the temperature drops as they approach a high-ceilinged cylindrical room, an underground windowless tower where lighting depends on the amount of sun that can be reflected through a small opening above. Walking over tiles made of polished ancient tiger ore, they circle a floor-to-ceiling clear glass tube that houses the Hofmann apparatus. It is here, at a small opening, that visitors have their closest access to Charrière's pure, ancient oxygen.Redefining the Art-Science Experience'Breathe' represents a groundbreaking fusion of scientific methodology and artistic expression, challenging traditional boundaries between disciplines. The installation creates a profound personal experience that connects visitors not just to art, but to the very essence of life on Earth.What makes this installation particularly powerful is its claim that each visitor is the first human being to ever inhale that specific oxygen. As Charrière explains: 'You are breathing something which is so pure and has not been touched by any being before you... And the beauty of the piece is you will carry it until you die. You're going to become a small part of this installation and you become a big part of the great oxygen cycle, and you will only finally free this oxygen once... once you're going in the other world.'This installation is part of a broader trend in contemporary art that incorporates scientific processes and concepts, creating works that are both intellectually stimulating and viscerally impactful.The Future of Scientific Art Installations'Breathe' is opening alongside Charrière's major new exhibition 'Hard Core,' which showcases both the ambition and scientific curiosity of the Berlin-based artist. Individual elements of 'Hard Core' have been exhibited elsewhere in the world, including at the Venice Biennale, but the full exhibition finds its perfect home at Mona, with its exposed rock, industrial aesthetic, and fusion of science with art.As museums and galleries continue to seek innovative ways to engage audiences, installations like 'Breathe' point to a future where art and science are not just displayed together but are fundamentally intertwined in the creative process. This approach has the potential to create more immersive, educational, and thought-provoking experiences that challenge visitors to see the world—and their place in it—in new ways.Charrière's work demonstrates how art can make abstract scientific concepts tangible and personal, creating connections across vast stretches of time and space. As our understanding of the universe expands, art installations like 'Breathe' will play an increasingly important role in helping us process and relate to these profound concepts.

The Comeback That Never MaterializedJust over a year ago, Lizzo appeared on Saturday Night Live, announcing a new album called Love in Real Life in grandstanding style. Wielding an electric guitar, clad in a Trump-baiting T-shirt that read Tariffied, she performed its title track and two other new songs, Still Bad and Don't Make Me Love U. As with her appearance earlier the same week on a late night talkshow – during which she ran into the audience to high-five fans who were yelling "we love you Lizzo!" – it looked very much like a defiant comeback, fit to drag her out of the controversy that erupted at the end of her hugely successful 2023 world tour. Three former backing dancers and a costume designer filed lawsuits against the singer alleging harassment and discrimination: damaging claims given how Lizzo's songs have preached a message of inclusivity, body positivity and self-confidence. Some of the allegations were dismissed by a judge but others are ongoing; Lizzo has refused to settle out of court, saying: "I'm fighting the case because I know that it's not true."The Album That Never WasBut the Love in Real Life single, a pivot towards rock that owed a little to Tom Petty's American Girls – or the Strokes' American Girls-indebted Last Nite if you prefer – failed to make the charts, a far cry from the period between 2018 and 2022 when Lizzo's singles seemed to go multi-platinum as a matter of course. The same fate befell Still Bad, a track much more in the vein of her big hits, prompting a rethink. The album was pulled, Lizzo apparently taking control of her own destiny – "I need to do shit my way". A mixtape that returned her more-or-less to where she started, before pop stardom came calling – punchy hip-hop, albeit tricked out with guest appearances from Doja Cat and SZA – appeared in its place: My Face Hurts from Smiling received mixed reviews and underwhelming streaming figures.A Career at a CrossroadsAll of which means that Bitch, her fifth album proper, lands at a deeply peculiar juncture in Lizzo's career. Given that the public apparently don't want her going rock, nor rapping in the style of her 2013 debut Lizzobangers, nor indeed making the kind of music they were buying in their millions three years ago, the question of what they actually do want has presumably hung heavy over its making.Musical Identity CrisisLizzo hasn't come up with a definitive answer. Bitch tries a bit of everything, from pastiching Tame Impala on Happy 2 Be to making clipped new-wave rock decorated with Cure-like guitars on She Stole My Man; Sexy Ladies is a girls-night-out-soundtracking reiteration of the old body positivity message. This scatter-gun approach makes Bitch a disjointed listen.The Subdued ToneMoreover, there's something oddly subdued about its tone, whether it's dabbling in 80s retro – Don't Make Me Love U brings to mind the arena-rousing keyboard hook from Tina Turner's The Best, but renders it into a distant, affectless backing vocal – or delving into jazzy R&B; on Too Nice. The vibraphone-heavy beat on the latter is fantastic, rich in small-hours atmosphere, but the actual song feels nondescript: it only really comes to life in its dying moments, when Lizzo stops singing and starts playing a flute solo. The title track interpolates the chorus from Meredith Brooks' 1997 pop-grunge hit of the same name, but somehow flattens it in the process. Crooned over smooth, G-funky R&B;, it feels stripped of its fiery power, less of a snarl and more of a shrug.Equivocal LyricsThe lyrics often seem similarly equivocal. You don't want for apparent references to Lizzo's recent woes – "I hope it makes you happy to hurt somebody else", "the thing about depression, you think your life is over", "you'd still be working at the mall if it wasn't for me" – but they ultimately feel neither pugilistic nor racked, just confused and sore: "I have feelings too," she sings on piano ballad A Toast.Highlights Amidst the StruggleNot everything here is underwhelming: Whose Hair Is This is a great southern soul pastiche, home to an impressively raw vocal and a snappy plot twist at the end of the lyrics; That Grrrl employs an old-school Chicago house bassline to energising effect. But what's definitely lacking is an unequivocal pop smash, the kind of thing that Lizzo once seemed to be able to write to order.A Changing Cultural LandscapePerhaps that's inevitable. One of the reasons Lizzo hit so big in the first place was that she made pop music that perfectly captured a zeitgeist, and that zeitgeist has moved on: the era of body positivity has been displaced by the era of Ozempic and Mounjaro; the kind of post-pandemic, post-Trump optimism embodied on 2022's About Damn Time now sounds like a transmission from a distant lost age. We're living in a different world now, and Bitch suggests Lizzo has yet to work out how to respond to it: "I'm doing my best," she sings on A Toast, which feels like the most telling lyric of all.