Tech
May 27, 2026
Scotland's 'Green Datacentres' Policy Under Fire for Ignoring AI Emissions
Scotland's policy to encourage 'green datacentres' may ignore significant carbon emissions from AI …
The Misguided 'Green Datacentres' Policy
A Scottish government policy aimed at attracting datacentres to build in Scotland has been criticized for ignoring the emissions impact of AI developments. The policy, which encourages 'green datacentres', lacks a clear definition of what constitutes a 'green datacentre', potentially allowing developers to claim their projects are environmentally friendly despite significant emissions.
The Problem with Unclear Definitions
The Scottish charity Action to Protect Rural Scotland (APRS) has raised concerns that the policy's lack of clarity could lead to developers receiving favourable treatment from local authorities, even if their projects have substantial emissions. APRS found that a datacentre in Edinburgh was able to argue it was a 'green datacentre' despite including 200 diesel backup generators, equivalent to 100,000 idling cars.
The Data Analysis
More than a dozen datacentres in Scotland are in the process of getting planning permission, including an AI growth zone in Lanarkshire, near Glasgow, which claims to be backed by £8.2bn in private investment. Collectively, they stand to use roughly 6.2GW of power – one-and-a-half times more than the peak power use of all of Scotland in the winter.
The Impact Analysis
The APRS has criticized the Scottish government's approach, saying that the underlying analysis used to support the policy was done in 2022, before the release of ChatGPT, and has not been updated since. This analysis concluded that any increase in emissions caused by datacentre use would be counterbalanced by a decrease in emissions as people travelled less, but it does not take into account the development of AI or its potentially massive energy consumption.
The Prediction
As the demand for datacentres continues to grow, driven in part by the development of AI, Scotland's policy on 'green datacentres' is likely to face increasing scrutiny. With more than 100 datacentre projects requesting gas connections, indicating they plan to burn gas to power themselves, the UK's climate goals may be at risk. The Scottish government will need to revisit its policy and provide clearer definitions and guidelines for what constitutes a 'green datacentre' to ensure that its ambitions for economic growth align with its net zero ambitions.
#Scotland
#datacentres
#AI
Read More